/* ======================================================================== * Copyright (c) 2005-2026 The OPC Foundation, Inc. All rights reserved. * * OPC Foundation MIT License 1.00 * * Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person * obtaining a copy of this software and associated documentation * files (the "Software"), to deal in the Software without * restriction, including without limitation the rights to use, * copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell * copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom the * Software is furnished to do so, subject to the following * conditions: * * The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be * included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software. * THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, * EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES * OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND * NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT * HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER LIABILITY, * WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING * FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR * OTHER DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE. * * The complete license agreement can be found here: * http://opcfoundation.org/License/MIT/1.00/ * ======================================================================*/ using System; using System.Collections.Generic; using System.Threading.Tasks; using Microsoft.Extensions.Logging.Abstractions; using NUnit.Framework; using Opc.Ua.PubSub.StateMachine; namespace Opc.Ua.PubSub.Tests.StateMachine { /// /// Exhaustive coverage for the /// transition table and parent / child propagation rules per OPC UA /// Part 14 §6.2.1 (PubSubState), §9.1.10 (Enable / Disable rejection /// preconditions), and §9.1.3.5 (RemoveConnection: children must be /// disabled before the parent itself transitions to Disabled). /// [TestFixture] [TestSpec("6.2.1", Summary = "PubSubState enum and transition model")] [TestSpec("9.1.10", Summary = "Enable / Disable / state report rules")] [TestSpec("9.1.3.5", Summary = "Disable children before parent on removal")] public class PubSubStateMachineTests { private static PubSubStateMachine NewMachine( string name = "M", PubSubComponentKind kind = PubSubComponentKind.Connection) { return new(name, kind, NullLogger.Instance); } [Test] public void Constructor_SeedsDisabledStateAndStatusCode() { PubSubStateMachine sut = NewMachine(); Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Disabled)); Assert.That(sut.StatusCode, Is.EqualTo(StatusCodes.BadInvalidState)); Assert.That(sut.Parent, Is.Null); Assert.That(sut.Children, Is.Empty); Assert.That(sut.ComponentName, Is.EqualTo("M")); Assert.That(sut.ComponentKind, Is.EqualTo(PubSubComponentKind.Connection)); }); } [Test] public void Constructor_RejectsNullName() { Assert.That( () => new PubSubStateMachine(null!, PubSubComponentKind.Connection, NullLogger.Instance), Throws.ArgumentNullException); } [Test] public void Constructor_RejectsEmptyName() { Assert.That( () => new PubSubStateMachine(string.Empty, PubSubComponentKind.Connection, NullLogger.Instance), Throws.ArgumentException); } [Test] public void Constructor_RejectsNullLogger() { Assert.That( () => new PubSubStateMachine("M", PubSubComponentKind.Connection, null!), Throws.ArgumentNullException); } [Test] [TestSpec("9.1.10.2", Summary = "Enable from Disabled is allowed")] public void TryEnable_FromDisabled_TransitionsToPreOperational() { PubSubStateMachine sut = NewMachine(); PubSubStateChangedEventArgs? captured = null; sut.StateChanged += (_, e) => captured = e; bool result = sut.TryEnable(); Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(result, Is.True); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.PreOperational)); Assert.That(sut.StatusCode, Is.EqualTo(StatusCodes.GoodCallAgain)); Assert.That(captured, Is.Not.Null); Assert.That(captured!.PreviousState, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Disabled)); Assert.That(captured.NewState, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.PreOperational)); Assert.That(captured.Reason, Is.EqualTo(PubSubStateTransitionReason.ByMethod)); Assert.That(captured.ComponentName, Is.EqualTo("M")); Assert.That(captured.ComponentKind, Is.EqualTo(PubSubComponentKind.Connection)); }); } [Test] [TestSpec("9.1.10.2", Summary = "Enable from PreOperational/Operational/Paused/Error is rejected")] public void TryEnable_FromNonDisabledStates_IsRejected( [Values( PubSubState.PreOperational, PubSubState.Operational, PubSubState.Paused, PubSubState.Error)] PubSubState startState) { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(startState); int events = 0; sut.StateChanged += (_, _) => events++; bool result = sut.TryEnable(); Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(result, Is.False); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(startState)); Assert.That(events, Is.Zero); }); } [Test] public void TryMarkOperational_FromPreOperational_Transitions() { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(PubSubState.PreOperational); Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(sut.TryMarkOperational(), Is.True); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Operational)); Assert.That(sut.StatusCode, Is.EqualTo(StatusCodes.Good)); }); } [Test] public void TryMarkOperational_FromError_RecoversToOperational() { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(PubSubState.Error); Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(sut.TryMarkOperational(PubSubStateTransitionReason.FromError), Is.True); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Operational)); }); } [Test] public void TryMarkOperational_FromDisabledOrPaused_IsRejected( [Values(PubSubState.Disabled, PubSubState.Paused)] PubSubState startState) { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(startState); bool result = sut.TryMarkOperational(); Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(result, Is.False); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(startState)); }); } [Test] [TestSpec("9.1.10", Summary = "TryMarkOperational from Operational is rejected (strict transition)")] public void TryMarkOperational_FromOperational_IsRejected_AndNoEventFires() { // The allowed source set for MarkOperational is {PreOperational, Error}. // Operational is NOT in that set, so the call is rejected. This is // intentional: idempotent same-state re-assertion is not part of the // public API; callers must observe State first. PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational); int events = 0; sut.StateChanged += (_, _) => events++; Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(sut.TryMarkOperational(), Is.False); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Operational)); Assert.That(events, Is.Zero); }); } [Test] public void TryPause_FromOperational_Transitions() { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational); Assert.That(sut.TryPause(), Is.True); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Paused)); } [Test] public void TryPause_FromPreOperational_Transitions() { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(PubSubState.PreOperational); Assert.That(sut.TryPause(), Is.True); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Paused)); } [Test] public void TryPause_FromError_Transitions() { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(PubSubState.Error); Assert.That(sut.TryPause(), Is.True); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Paused)); } [Test] public void TryPause_FromDisabled_IsRejected() { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(PubSubState.Disabled); Assert.That(sut.TryPause(), Is.False); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Disabled)); } [Test] public void TryResume_FromPaused_TransitionsToPreOperational() { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(PubSubState.Paused); Assert.That(sut.TryResume(), Is.True); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.PreOperational)); } [Test] public void TryResume_FromAnyOtherState_IsRejected( [Values( PubSubState.Disabled, PubSubState.PreOperational, PubSubState.Operational, PubSubState.Error)] PubSubState startState) { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(startState); Assert.That(sut.TryResume(), Is.False); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(startState)); } [Test] public void TryFault_FromPreOperationalOperationalOrError_MovesToError( [Values( PubSubState.PreOperational, PubSubState.Operational, PubSubState.Error)] PubSubState startState) { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(startState); bool result = sut.TryFault(StatusCodes.BadCommunicationError); Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(result, Is.True); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Error)); Assert.That(sut.StatusCode, Is.EqualTo(StatusCodes.BadCommunicationError)); }); } [Test] public void TryFault_FromPaused_IsRejected() { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(PubSubState.Paused); bool result = sut.TryFault(StatusCodes.BadCommunicationError); Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(result, Is.False); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Paused)); }); } [Test] public void TryFault_FromDisabled_IsRejected() { PubSubStateMachine sut = NewMachine(); bool result = sut.TryFault(StatusCodes.BadCommunicationError); Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(result, Is.False); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Disabled)); }); } [Test] [TestSpec("9.1.10.3", Summary = "Disable from already-Disabled is rejected")] public void TryDisable_FromAlreadyDisabled_IsRejected() { PubSubStateMachine sut = NewMachine(); bool result = sut.TryDisable(); Assert.That(result, Is.False); } [Test] public void TryDisable_FromAnyNonDisabledState_TransitionsToDisabled( [Values( PubSubState.PreOperational, PubSubState.Operational, PubSubState.Paused, PubSubState.Error)] PubSubState startState) { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(startState); Assert.That(sut.TryDisable(), Is.True); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Disabled)); } [Test] [TestSpec("9.1.3.5", Summary = "Children disabled before parent on cascading Disable")] public void TryDisable_DisablesChildrenBeforeSelf_InOrder() { PubSubStateMachine parent = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational, "parent"); PubSubStateMachine child1 = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational, "child1"); PubSubStateMachine child2 = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational, "child2"); parent.AttachChild(child1); parent.AttachChild(child2); var observed = new List<(string Component, PubSubState State, PubSubStateTransitionReason Reason)>(); EventHandler handler = (_, e) => observed.Add((e.ComponentName, e.NewState, e.Reason)); parent.StateChanged += handler; child1.StateChanged += handler; child2.StateChanged += handler; bool result = parent.TryDisable(); Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(result, Is.True); Assert.That(parent.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Disabled)); Assert.That(child1.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Disabled)); Assert.That(child2.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Disabled)); Assert.That(observed, Has.Count.EqualTo(3)); // Children disabled before parent. Assert.That(observed[0].Component, Is.EqualTo("child1")); Assert.That(observed[0].Reason, Is.EqualTo(PubSubStateTransitionReason.ByParent)); Assert.That(observed[1].Component, Is.EqualTo("child2")); Assert.That(observed[1].Reason, Is.EqualTo(PubSubStateTransitionReason.ByParent)); Assert.That(observed[2].Component, Is.EqualTo("parent")); Assert.That(observed[2].Reason, Is.EqualTo(PubSubStateTransitionReason.ByMethod)); }); } [Test] public void TryDisable_RemovedReason_PropagatesRemovedToChildren() { PubSubStateMachine parent = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational, "p"); PubSubStateMachine child = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational, "c"); parent.AttachChild(child); PubSubStateTransitionReason? childReason = null; child.StateChanged += (_, e) => childReason = e.Reason; parent.TryDisable(PubSubStateTransitionReason.Removed); Assert.That(childReason, Is.EqualTo(PubSubStateTransitionReason.Removed)); } [Test] public void TryPauseCascade_PausesAllPausableChildrenThenSelf() { PubSubStateMachine parent = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational, "p"); PubSubStateMachine child1 = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational, "c1"); PubSubStateMachine child2 = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational, "c2"); parent.AttachChild(child1); parent.AttachChild(child2); Assert.That(parent.TryPauseCascade(), Is.True); Assert.That(parent.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Paused)); Assert.That(child1.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Paused)); Assert.That(child2.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Paused)); } [Test] public void TryPauseCascade_RecursesIntoGrandchildren() { PubSubStateMachine app = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational, "app"); PubSubStateMachine conn = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational, "conn"); PubSubStateMachine group = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational, "group"); app.AttachChild(conn); conn.AttachChild(group); app.TryPauseCascade(); Assert.That(group.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Paused)); Assert.That(conn.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Paused)); Assert.That(app.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Paused)); } [Test] public void AttachChild_NullChild_Throws() { PubSubStateMachine parent = NewMachine(); Assert.That(() => parent.AttachChild(null!), Throws.ArgumentNullException); } [Test] public void AttachChild_SelfReference_Throws() { PubSubStateMachine sut = NewMachine(); Assert.That(() => sut.AttachChild(sut), Throws.InvalidOperationException); } [Test] public void AttachChild_DoubleParent_Throws() { PubSubStateMachine parent1 = NewMachine("p1"); PubSubStateMachine parent2 = NewMachine("p2"); PubSubStateMachine child = NewMachine("c"); parent1.AttachChild(child); Assert.That(() => parent2.AttachChild(child), Throws.InvalidOperationException); } [Test] public void DetachChild_RemovesParentLink() { PubSubStateMachine parent = NewMachine("p"); PubSubStateMachine child = NewMachine("c"); parent.AttachChild(child); parent.DetachChild(child); Assert.That(child.Parent, Is.Null); Assert.That(parent.Children, Is.Empty); } [Test] public void DetachChild_OfUnknownChild_IsNoOp() { PubSubStateMachine parent = NewMachine("p"); PubSubStateMachine other = NewMachine("o"); Assert.That(() => parent.DetachChild(other), Throws.Nothing); Assert.That(other.Parent, Is.Null); } [Test] public void DetachChild_NullArgument_Throws() { PubSubStateMachine parent = NewMachine("p"); Assert.That(() => parent.DetachChild(null!), Throws.ArgumentNullException); } [Test] public void MarkRemoved_DisablesAndDetachesFromParent() { PubSubStateMachine parent = NewMachine("p"); PubSubStateMachine child = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational, "c"); parent.AttachChild(child); child.MarkRemoved(); Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(child.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Disabled)); Assert.That(parent.Children, Is.Empty); }); } [Test] public void MarkRemoved_IsIdempotent() { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational); sut.MarkRemoved(); Assert.That(sut.MarkRemoved, Throws.Nothing); } [Test] public void AttachChild_AfterMarkRemoved_Throws() { PubSubStateMachine sut = NewMachine(); sut.MarkRemoved(); PubSubStateMachine child = NewMachine("c"); Assert.That(() => sut.AttachChild(child), Throws.InvalidOperationException); } [Test] public void Transition_AfterMarkRemoved_Throws() { PubSubStateMachine sut = NewMachine(); sut.MarkRemoved(); Assert.That(() => sut.TryEnable(), Throws.InvalidOperationException); } [Test] public void StateChanged_HandlerException_IsSwallowedAndStateRemains() { PubSubStateMachine sut = NewMachine(); sut.StateChanged += (_, _) => throw new InvalidOperationException("bad listener"); Assert.That(() => sut.TryEnable(), Throws.Nothing); Assert.That(sut.State, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.PreOperational)); } public static IEnumerable DefaultStatusCodeFor_TestCases() { yield return new TestCaseData(PubSubState.Operational, StatusCodes.Good); yield return new TestCaseData(PubSubState.Paused, StatusCodes.GoodNoData); yield return new TestCaseData(PubSubState.PreOperational, StatusCodes.GoodCallAgain); yield return new TestCaseData(PubSubState.Error, StatusCodes.BadInternalError); yield return new TestCaseData(PubSubState.Disabled, StatusCodes.BadInvalidState); } [Test] [TestCaseSource(nameof(DefaultStatusCodeFor_TestCases))] public void DefaultStatusCodeFor_KnownState_ReturnsCanonicalStatus( PubSubState state, StatusCode expected) { StatusCode code = PubSubStateMachine.DefaultStatusCodeFor(state); Assert.That(code, Is.EqualTo(expected)); } [Test] public void DefaultStatusCodeFor_OutOfRangeState_ReturnsBadUnexpected() { StatusCode code = PubSubStateMachine.DefaultStatusCodeFor((PubSubState)99); Assert.That(code, Is.EqualTo(StatusCodes.BadUnexpectedError)); } [Test] public void EventArgs_NullComponentName_Throws() { Assert.That( () => new PubSubStateChangedEventArgs( null!, PubSubComponentKind.Connection, PubSubState.Disabled, PubSubState.PreOperational, PubSubStateTransitionReason.ByMethod, StatusCodes.Good), Throws.ArgumentNullException); } [Test] public void EventArgs_ValidArguments_ExposesAllProperties() { var evt = new PubSubStateChangedEventArgs( "C", PubSubComponentKind.DataSetReader, PubSubState.Operational, PubSubState.Error, PubSubStateTransitionReason.Fatal, StatusCodes.BadCommunicationError); Assert.Multiple(() => { Assert.That(evt.ComponentName, Is.EqualTo("C")); Assert.That(evt.ComponentKind, Is.EqualTo(PubSubComponentKind.DataSetReader)); Assert.That(evt.PreviousState, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Operational)); Assert.That(evt.NewState, Is.EqualTo(PubSubState.Error)); Assert.That(evt.Reason, Is.EqualTo(PubSubStateTransitionReason.Fatal)); Assert.That(evt.StatusCode, Is.EqualTo(StatusCodes.BadCommunicationError)); }); } [Test] public async Task ConcurrentTransitions_LeaveMachineInConsistentState() { PubSubStateMachine sut = SetupInState(PubSubState.Operational); var tasks = new List(); for (int i = 0; i < 32; i++) { tasks.Add(Task.Run(() => sut.TryPause())); tasks.Add(Task.Run(() => sut.TryResume())); tasks.Add(Task.Run(() => sut.TryFault(StatusCodes.BadCommunicationError))); tasks.Add(Task.Run(() => sut.TryMarkOperational(PubSubStateTransitionReason.FromError))); } await Task.WhenAll(tasks).ConfigureAwait(false); // Final state must be one of the four reachable states; never Disabled (we didn't disable). Assert.That( sut.State, Is.AnyOf( PubSubState.Operational, PubSubState.PreOperational, PubSubState.Paused, PubSubState.Error)); } private static PubSubStateMachine SetupInState( PubSubState target, string name = "M", PubSubComponentKind kind = PubSubComponentKind.Connection) { var sut = new PubSubStateMachine(name, kind, NullLogger.Instance); switch (target) { case PubSubState.Disabled: break; case PubSubState.PreOperational: Assert.That(sut.TryEnable(), Is.True); break; case PubSubState.Operational: Assert.That(sut.TryEnable(), Is.True); Assert.That(sut.TryMarkOperational(), Is.True); break; case PubSubState.Paused: Assert.That(sut.TryEnable(), Is.True); Assert.That(sut.TryMarkOperational(), Is.True); Assert.That(sut.TryPause(), Is.True); break; case PubSubState.Error: Assert.That(sut.TryEnable(), Is.True); Assert.That(sut.TryFault(StatusCodes.BadCommunicationError), Is.True); break; default: throw new ArgumentOutOfRangeException(nameof(target)); } return sut; } } }