Files
UA-.NETStandard/docs/Programs.md
T
Marc Schier 2836da7ec8 Fix sessionless ResultTransfer ownership bypass and other issues. (#4834)
# Description

Correct ownership, endpoint validation, policy propagation, subscription
delivery, file handling and generated-model behavior across the stack,
tools and samples. Add focused regression tests and update the
corresponding guides and sample documentation.

### Previously included corrections

- Require an active, matching session to generate or access transient
ResultTransfer file handles. Cover both sessionless generation and reads
against a handle owned by an active session, using live session owners
in the Machinery tests.
- Keep physical filesystem operations within their configured mount and
apply the same confinement checks throughout file operations.
- Validate LDS semaphore paths consistently during server registration
and registration-store maintenance.

### Individual issues addressed

| # | Component | Issue and correction |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | AI jobs and transfers | Jobs and transfers did not consistently
retain their creator's identity and session. Apply ownership checks to
descendants, file handles, subscriptions and execution, and recheck
deployment permissions before dispatch. |
| 2 | Password-management client | Password-bearing calls could use
signing-only channels or follow a replacement connection. Capture an
encrypted transport generation and keep dispatch bound to it; preserve
ordinary non-password edits. |
| 3 | GDS and certificate-push clients | Connections omitted hostname
verification. Validate the original configured DNS name or IP address
before session activation. |
| 4 | Certificate push | Private-key uploads could use signing-only
calls. Require an encrypted, generation-bound dispatch while preserving
certificate-only updates and restoring the caller's identity afterward.
|
| 5 | MQTT client | The .NET Framework custom-trust callback could
discard TLS hostname, certificate-availability and usage errors. Retain
those checks while supporting configured issuer trust. |
| 6 | DTLS handshake | Certificate trust was not tied to the configured
peer address. Match the certificate's DNS or IP identity to the intended
endpoint. |
| 7 | Replicated address spaces | Serialized nodes lost per-node and
descendant permission metadata. Preserve role permissions, user-role
permissions and access restrictions, including updates to existing
replica nodes. |
| 8 | MCP PubSub imports | Imports without groups skipped checks on the
effective broker destination. Check the actual endpoint before resolving
credentials or activating the connection. |
| 9 | Reference-server accounts | A disabled username account could
authenticate again with its previous roles. Reject disabled accounts
during fresh authentication. |
| 10 | Console reference client | The sample disabled hostname checks
when connecting to an otherwise trusted peer. Retain the original
requested host and validate it before activation. |
| 11 | Capture replay and export | Replay and raw export could accept
non-capture files or include key material. Require complete PCAP/PCAPNG
containers and exclude key sidecars and decryption-secret blocks. |
| 12 | PubSub adapter fallback | The fallback client configuration
automatically accepted peer certificates. Apply normal trust and
hostname validation before activation or reads. |
| 13 | Kafka transport | Explicit TLS enablement was checked but did not
reach both final Confluent configurations. Use the same effective
protocol for validation, producers and consumers. |
| 14 | PubSub actions | Configuration rebuilds could widen a
connection-local action handler's scope. Preserve its original
connection association and reject mismatched dispatch. |
| 15 | PubSub readers | Reader-level message-protection settings were
accepted but ignored. Apply the effective group and reader settings
before accepting and publishing received values. |
| 16 | PubSub key groups | Different `SecurityGroupId` values could
share one connection-wide key context. Reject mixed groups on a
connection and require separate connections for distinct groups. |
| 17 | MCP session registrations | Session-name replacement or reuse
could retain another registration's credential bindings. Bind access to
the registration, caller and authenticated endpoint, and preserve that
identity when borrowing sessions. |
| 18 | Viewer HTTP host | Requests reached the viewer's OPC UA session
without consistent Host, Origin and port checks. Validate the request
destination and browser origin before using the session, while retaining
supported local MCP clients. |
| 19 | Vision file operations | File operations did not consistently
apply protected-file checks, and remote handles lacked caller and
connection context. Apply the shared checks and use host-side opaque
handles bound to caller, target and generation. |
| 20 | DTLS record integrity | The integrity-only MAC used a truncated
sequence number. Authenticate the full reconstructed sequence number and
epoch so records remain distinct across rollover. |
| 21 | AMB client sample | Connection setup omitted hostname validation.
Preserve the originally requested host and verify the peer identity
before activation. |
| 22 | Robot sample writes | The R2 `SpeedOverride` callback could
target R1 state. Bind each callback to its own robot and apply that
robot's write policy. |
| 23 | AI result properties | Optional result children inherited
remotely writable defaults. Preserve their declaration restrictions and
keep server-produced results read-only. |
| 24 | WSS peer-trust updates | Existing channels did not consistently
respond to peer-trust changes. Revalidate complete chains for forward
and reverse WSS channels and close only those that no longer validate. |
| 25 | GDS revocation checks | Caller-provided certificates could cause
issuer retrieval from embedded URLs. Resolve validation from configured
local trust, issuers and CRLs without fetching caller-provided
locations. |
| 26 | GMS observations | Published correction observations retained
writable model defaults. Reject remote writes while preserving
publisher-side updates. |
| 27 | Production-dataset monitoring | Subscription admission and
delivery could use the reporter's context instead of each subscriber's
permissions. Evaluate the subscriber at admission and on every delivery,
including cancellation and disposal paths. |
| 28 | WoT MQTT destinations | Hostless MQTT forms could imply a
localhost destination before loopback checks. Reject them before
credential lookup or connection attempts and validate the effective
endpoint. |
| 29 | XRegistry opaque reads | Content-ID reads and notifications did
not consistently honor encrypted-read requirements or the currently
accepted transport. Recheck the bound endpoint and reject transport
downgrades before rebinding, including when protected values are already
queued. |
| 30 | PubSub capture dissection | Key loading did not consistently
check the configured capture-root boundary. Check each actual key path
immediately before opening it. |
| 31 | PubSub publication queues | Imported WriterGroup queues were not
fully checked against publish-topic grants. Check the destination
actually used by each group. |
| 32 | MCP PubSub mutations | A caller-supplied mode could select
subscribe grants for an operation that publishes. Derive the required
direction and parent context from the actual mutation. |
| 33 | Generated write masks | Model import and generation could widen
an explicit `UserWriteMask`. Preserve it through import, copy, merge,
inheritance and dependency metadata. |
| 34 | Generated method flags | An explicit `UserExecutable=false` could
be lost. Preserve its specified state and resulting method behavior
through the same model paths. |
| 35 | Generated role identifiers | Unresolved role identifiers could
cause permission entries to be omitted. Preserve namespace-qualified
role IDs and report a diagnostic when a policy cannot be represented. |
| 36 | Aggregation-server defaults | The `localhost` default did not
reliably constrain listener binding. Use numeric loopback for the
default endpoint and command-line fallback. |
| 37 | Certificate-validation cache | Cached results could skip current
leaf or issuer validity checks. Recheck validity windows on cache hits
and keep hostname validation independent of cached chain trust. |
| 38 | Software-update folders | Revision names and marker contents
containing dot segments could select paths outside the software root.
Normalize and check every derived path against that root. |
| 39 | USDA arrays | Array elements were not encoded for their string or
asset context. Escape them as data and preserve valid composition and
round-trip behavior. |
| 40 | Adapter hot reload | A changed dataset definition with the same
name could keep old fields, subscriptions or cached values active.
Compare complete immutable definitions and retire old state before
replacement. |
| 41 | Adapter index ranges | Subscription publication could ignore
`IndexRange` and return the complete value. Preserve the requested
projection and its status and timestamps; reject unsupported range
providers. |
| 42 | PubSub metadata and targets | Metadata from one connection could
change another connection's target mapping. Scope metadata to its
connection and provenance, and resolve targets using actual typed field
IDs rather than field names or unintended positional fallback. |
| 43 | Scales product locks | Product locks were not applied across
every remote mutation path. Apply them consistently to value writes,
filling calculations and related recipe/controller operations while
retaining permitted updates. |
| 44 | Event permission caching | Cached event decisions could outlive
identity, role or node-policy changes. Revalidate the current
subscriber, event type and source permissions instead of reusing a stale
decision. |
| 45 | WoT Modbus destinations | Hostless Modbus forms could imply
localhost before loopback checks. Reject them before connecting and
validate the effective endpoint. |
| 46 | MCP local PKI tools | Peer-trust mutations did not consistently
require the caller's `CertificateAdministration` grant. Check the
capability before trust and untrust operations. |
| 47 | Robot-control HTTP bridge | The bridge lacked consistent Host,
Origin and port validation and caller-specific session grants. Apply
those checks before borrowing the OPC UA session and retain supported
local clients. |
| 48 | Subscription transfers | Transferred subscriptions could retain
cached notifications after the destination's permissions changed.
Require authorization continuity between source and destination
identities and roles, invalidate stale retransmission data when
continuity fails, and preserve retransmission behavior for compatible
transfers. |

### Compatibility notes

- Replication uses the versioned NSRP v1 policy envelope. Upgrade peers
together and re-encode or reseed legacy topology from the authoritative
model; missing permission metadata is not inferred from old records.
- Integrity-only DTLS peers must be upgraded together for the full
sequence/epoch MAC. AEAD behavior is unchanged.
- Distinct PubSub key groups require separate connections.
- Custom sessions that cannot capture the actual encrypted transport,
and subscription providers that cannot honor a requested range, are
rejected rather than silently changing the requested behavior.
- Subscription transfers retain retransmission data only when the
destination authorization remains compatible with the source snapshot;
otherwise the old sequence numbers and cached data are invalidated.

## Related Issues

No separate tracking issue is linked. The individual corrections are
listed above.

## Checklist

_Put an `x` in the boxes that apply. You can complete these step by step
after opening the PR._

- [ ] I have signed the
[CLA](https://opcfoundation.org/license/cla/ContributorLicenseAgreementv1.0.pdf)
and read the
[CONTRIBUTING](https://github.com/OPCFoundation/UA-.NETStandard/blob/master/CONTRIBUTING.md)
doc.
- [x] I have added tests that prove my fix is effective or that my
feature works and increased code coverage.
- [ ] I have added all necessary documentation.
- [x] I have verified that my changes do not introduce (new) build or
analyzer warnings.
- [ ] I ran **all** tests locally using the **UA.slnx** solution against
at least .net **framework** and .net **10**, and all passed.
- [ ] I fixed **all** failing and flaky tests in the CI pipelines and
**all** CodeQL warnings.
- [ ] I have addressed **all** PR feedback received.
2026-10-21 05:37:29 +02:00

12 KiB

Programs (OPC UA Part 10)

Programs expose long-running, controllable work through the four base states Halted, Ready, Running and Suspended. They are not arbitrary code-execution endpoints. An application registers an execution provider and its information model; clients invoke the published methods and monitor transitions and results.

The SDK builds on Part 16 state machines, generated node states and client proxies, node management, and streaming subscriptions. No separate Programs package is required: shared contracts/model are in Core, execution/hosting in Server, and discovery/observation in Client.

Register a Program

Select the lifetime policy and supported controls explicitly:

using Microsoft.Extensions.DependencyInjection;
using Opc.Ua;
using Opc.Ua.Programs;
using Opc.Ua.Server.Programs;
using ProgramTypes = Opc.Ua.Programs.ObjectTypeIds;

IProgramProvider provider = new DelegateProgramProvider(CreateExecutionAsync);
var definition = new ProgramDefinition(
    ProgramTypes.ManagedProgramType,
    static parent => new ManagedProgramState(parent),
    provider,
    [ProgramControlMethod.Start, ProgramControlMethod.Suspend,
        ProgramControlMethod.Resume, ProgramControlMethod.Halt,
        ProgramControlMethod.Reset],
    ProgramState.Ready,
    maxInstanceCount: 4,
    maxRecycleCount: 10)
{
    Creatable = true,
    Deletable = true,
    AutoDelete = false
};

services.AddOpcUa()
    .AddServer(options => { /* endpoint and authentication configuration */ })
    .AddPrograms([definition]);

CreateExecutionAsync is application code returning a fresh IProgramExecution for an invocation. Its ControlAsync accepts or rejects a control and returns the method's outputs; it must not wait for the entire workload. Its ObserveAsync stream reports internal progress/completion, tagged with the RunId received when Start was accepted. DisposeAsync releases its resources. Control handlers must not await consumption of their own update stream: return acceptance first, then report subsequent internal changes. Unexpected observation failures halt the Program; an accepted Reset restarts observation.

Registration alone does not create or start work. ProgramNodeManagerFactory provides the non-DI path. ProgramNodeManager.CreateInvocationAsync creates server-owned invocations; AdoptInvocationAsync accepts an exclusively owned, unindexed generated node. Both use the same capacity accounting as client creation. ProgramRuntime.AttachAsync is the direct per-invocation path; its caller owns indexing newly materialized children and disposing the runtime. For address-space attachment, pass startObserving: false, index the children, then call ActivateAsync. The supplied node manager performs this sequence automatically; failed registration cannot start an observation loop. ActivateAsync waits until the provider's first enumeration request has begun before enabling controls. A hot-source provider must install its observer before that request yields; providers with asynchronous setup must buffer updates until setup completes. Reset uses the same readiness ordering when restarting a failed observation stream.

For a custom Program, pass its generated node factory and type identifier. The optional model loader on AddPrograms supplies its generated node collection. Different workloads should register distinct concrete Program types, not overwrite the policy on a shared namespace-zero type. An IProgramCreationAdapter adapts a declared application-specific Create signature to the same checked lifecycle. ParseAsync returns the parent, BrowseName and provider arguments; CompleteAsync constructs the declared outputs. Arguments reach the provider through ProgramInvocationContext.CreationArguments. Invalid outputs roll back the new invocation rather than leaking capacity.

Execution and lifetime

ProgramDiagnostic2 and its diagnostic value descendants are readable only by the creating session or a SecurityAdmin, over a confidential channel. Monitoring applies the same authorization as direct reads. Diagnostic value-read authorizers are registered with the owning node manager and released with the Program runtime; unrelated subscribers cannot retain access through a previously authorized subscription.

Control Allowed transition
Start Ready to Running
Suspend Running to Suspended
Resume Suspended to Running
Halt Ready, Running or Suspended to Halted
Reset Halted to Ready

Internal updates follow the same nine-transition graph. Initial resource availability can move Halted to Ready using RunId zero. An autonomous Ready-to-Running transition uses the next RunId and consumes the same restart allowance as Start; subsequent updates use that generation. Submachine updates identify a descendant state machine and its transition. They do not count as a new run. Unsupported controls need not be materialized; the remaining controls expose state-sensitive Executable/UserExecutable attributes.

The runtime validates and prepares transitions before awaiting control acceptance, then commits only if the captured state revision is still current. Guards run once, before provider side effects. A stale report from an earlier run cannot terminate a subsequent run. Do not mutate a runtime-owned node through the legacy FSM methods or another independently attached behavior. For a model-declared nested machine, StateMachineBuilder.BindSubStateMachine reuses the Part 16 activation machinery. Preserve state on reentry for Suspend/Resume; a new Program run resets its nested machines to their initial states. Inactive machines report BadStateNotActive and reject transitions.

Request cancellation and workload lifetime are different. Cancellation or a lost response after acceptance does not mean that the Program stopped. Controls are not automatically replayed. Providers must handle external side effects and ambiguous outcomes; local state management cannot roll back physical equipment or guarantee exactly-once execution across a network.

RecycleCount starts at zero and counts successful restarts after the first Start, not Reset or Resume. Rejected starts do not consume the allowance or clear retained results. After the allowance is exhausted, a completed Program remains Halted: Reset and subsequent Start are not executable, and an internal completion must target Halted rather than Ready. InstanceCount counts committed live invocations of the concrete type. Capacity is reserved while asynchronous creation is in progress.

Client deletion requires Deletable, authorization and Halted. AutoDelete acts after an execution terminates, not merely because an invocation was initialized in Halted. Terminal results/events are captured before removal. Auto-deleted results cannot subsequently be read.

The default state is in memory. Shutdown releases owned resources; there is no durable restart recovery, failover execution, or distributed scheduling in this feature. An injectable provider may manage external resources, but that does not turn the in-memory invocation registry into a replicated store.

Typed client use

using Opc.Ua;
using Opc.Ua.Client;
using Opc.Ua.Client.Programs;
using Opc.Ua.Programs;

var programs = new ProgramClient(session, telemetry);
NodeId invocationId = await programs.CreateAsync(
    programTypeId, programsFolderId, new QualifiedName("Job1", instanceNamespace), ct);
ProgramStateMachineTypeClient program = programs.GetProgram(invocationId);

await program.WaitForProgramTransitionAsync(
    streaming,
    notifierId: ObjectIds.Server,
    targetState: ProgramState.Running,
    onReady: token => program.StartAsync(token),
    ct: ct);

var capabilities = await programs.ReadCapabilitiesAsync(invocationId, ct);
var diagnostics = await programs.ReadDiagnosticsAsync(invocationId, ct);
var finalResults = await programs.ReadFinalResultsAsync(invocationId, ct);

await program.HaltAsync(ct);
await programs.DeleteAsync(invocationId, ct);

The Create convenience targets the SDK model's declared type-level signature: ParentId and BrowseName in, InvocationId out. Part 3 does not define universal Create arguments. Use an application's generated proxy for a vendor-specific Create or argument-bearing Start; do not infer the returned NodeId from an arbitrary output position.

Program client factories are available through the client DI builder. Discovery is scoped to a supplied address-space root and recognizes Program subtypes. Optional components are distinguished from bad service/value results. Always inspect the status-bearing capability, diagnostic and final-result values.

Use ObserveProgramTransitionsAsync for intermediate results and ObserveProgramAuditsAsync for transition audit events. Their generated filters select the invocation's SourceNode even when subscribing to an owning Object or Server notifier. The readiness callback subscribes before issuing a control.

Events carry captured results and state identifiers. Watching CurrentState.Id and rereading Variables is not equivalent: it can miss fast transitions, submachine self-transitions, and the intermediate values that caused them. Multi-node reads are not transactional historical snapshots. Streaming is not a durable event journal; account for overflow, disconnects and cancellation.

Results, diagnostics and security

ProgramTransitionEventType.IntermediateResult is a BaseDataType Variable: use a Variant, including a generated structure when appropriate. The default SDK event is a concrete subtype. Applications can select concrete event factories by namespace-aware transition NodeId. IntermediateResult is validated against the selected event's declared DataType and ValueRank.

Final results address declared Variables under FinalResultData. The runtime checks their type, captures their values, and retains them until an accepted rerun or deletion; Reset does not discard them.

ProgramDiagnostic2 contains creation identity/time, last transition time, last method/session/time, argument metadata and values, and return status. Its structured value and children are updated even when nobody subscribes. For rejected malformed calls, value arrays retain declaration positions, with null values for missing positions; excess inputs are not invented as declared arguments.

Diagnostic identity and argument reads require an encrypted channel and the creating session or SecurityAdmin. Service authorization still applies. Do not use arbitrary Program arguments as a secret store. Audit events follow the server's auditing/access policy; a failed method is not a successful Program transition. Internal transitions are not attributed to the client that originally created the invocation.

Specification compatibility

The linked Part 10 document is v1.05.00; the namespace-zero model shipped by this repository is 1.05.07. The SDK preserves the model's wire types and records these inconsistencies:

Issue SDK behavior
Maximum limits are UInt32, but prose describes negative unlimited values UInt32.MaxValue means unlimited by documented SDK convention, not a normative assertion.
RecycleCount is Int32 while the prose calls it unsigned Preserve Int32. After overflow the Variable reports BadOutOfRange; unlimited execution continues.
Reset HasCause links conflict with method definitions Managed runtime uses Halted-to-Ready only. Legacy low-level Reset-from-Suspended remains for compatibility.
IntermediateResult prose describes an Object Preserve the formal Variable/BaseDataType definition.
Program transition/audit types are abstract Use concrete SDK or application subtypes without changing namespace zero.
Old runtime state numbers were 1-4 Correct to Halted=11, Ready=12, Running=13, Suspended=14. Standard NodeIds are unchanged.
Generated subtypes qualified inherited IDs with their own namespace Inherited base states/transitions resolve to their standard namespace-zero declarations.

The SDK model namespace is http://opcfoundation.org/UA/SDK/Programs/. It defines concrete events and a default Program type, not an Annex A production download engine. Annex A is an illustrative interoperability fixture. These implementation tests are not an OPC Foundation certification.